BerksFHS logo
Link to HomeBerksFHS Home   indexContents

Meeting Summaries Index
BerksFHS
Meeting Summary
18 May 2005, Computer Branch


‘How to find The Best Family History Program for you’

Chris Searle - 18 May 2005 - speaking at the BerksFHS Computer Branch, Woodley

Do you need a Family History Computer Program ?

• First of all, let's realize that you do not absolutely need a genealogy program
• Genealogies have been recorded for thousands of years without the use of graphical interfaces, a mouse, or multimedia files.

Methods of Recording Family History

• Family Histories have been successfully recorded using:-
- Hammer and chisel on stone
- Scribe on a clay tablet.
- Pencil and paper
•But this presentation is about using a Computer Program

With any good genealogy program, you can...

• Search and organize within a true database
• Enter name, dates, and localities for each ancestor one time
- then reuse the information in other records
• Print and view a variety of reports
- including Family group sheets
- Pedigree charts, Descendancy charts, and many more.
• Make updates (corrections) easily
• Integrate pictures, maps, drawings, video, and audio along with text
• Receive and share databases via GEDCOM files
To select the best program for you.
• You need to answer a range of questions to get a clear picture of your needs
- Do you want the option of printing family tree information in several different styles or in booklet form?
- Do you want to print wall charts complete with pictures of each individual?
- How about multimedia scrapbooks that you can show at a family reunion?

Do you want to purchase a genealogy program that includes:-

• CD-ROM disks containing the Social Security Death Index for the USA
• census records, and other information,
• Or would you prefer to rely on:-
- Paper-based documents
- Online research sites
- Archives on the Web
• Will you need to import and export information in specific file formats?

Do you want bells and whistles?

• Automatically search multiple Web sites for information on your ancestors
• Generate self-loading CD-ROM disks for distribution to family members
• Contain a list of all the sources you researched, a repository list, or a future tasks list
• Calendars Mailing Lists Correspondence Log
• Research Log Research Notes

What sort of System do you have?

• Are you using an older system with modest capabilities
• Do you have a modem
• Or do you have a Macintosh or some other non windows computer?
•Or do you have a high-speed modern computer with a huge disk drive and lots of memory?

What are you prepared to pay?

• You may be very happy with a free genealogy program
- today's free programs are far better than the £100+ plus programs of only a decade ago!
- although moving up to a paid program typically adds functionality.
• Today you have a large choice of programs at prices up to £75
- However, extra features are not always added in direct proportion to the price.

Try before you buy

• Keep in mind that whatever program you select probably will be used a lot.
• Most genealogists spend many hours seated at a computer
- Entering their family tree
- Sorting data
- Printing reports
- Or maybe creating online output.
• Your selection of genealogy software will represent a large investment of time, even if it is not a large financial investment.

I strongly suggest that you shop around. Download the demo versions of several programs and take them for a "test drive" to see which ones feel more comfortable to you.

GEDCOM

• Through the use of GEDCOM files, you can export data from one genealogy program and then later
import the same data into another program, assuming that both programs support GEDCOM
• You can exchange genealogy data with other people through the use of GEDCOM
• Many online databases accept data in GEDCOM format.
• Check that any program you are considering will support GEDCOM transfers.

Which of the following are most important to you?

• Ease of use · Price
• Source citations · Research notes
• Graphics · Photographs
• Slide shows · Videos
• Printouts · Calendars
• Mailing lists · Wall charts
• Creation of web pages · Ancestor charts
• Descendants charts · Drop line charts
• Register report · Data exchange
• Multiple languages · Multiple databases
• Integration with online genealogy databases
• Any other requirement that may be important to you

Mumford's Genealogical Report Cards

• Now no longer maintained but this used to be the most detailed online comparison of Windows
genealogy programs in existence go to:-
• http://www.mumford.ca/reportcard
- Local
• It is still a useful site as a reminder of what to look for and a comparison of what used to be
available.
• You should bear in mind that the programs listed have probably been updated.

Louis Kessler's Genealogy Software Links

• Louis lists his impressions of what he considers to be the four best genealogy programs as well as the three most popular.
• There are links to many other software reviews, written by a number of people.
• He includes links to accessory programs you may wish to use
• http://www.lkessler.com/gplinks.shtml

Louis Kessler's Behold

• Louis has decided to write his own program.
• It is still being developed and is still in its alpha stage.
• Currently it reads data from a Gedcom file but you cannot directly modify it.
• His presentation "a every thing report" is entirely different to other programs and the output is currently in htm format

Dick Eastman's Program Reviews

• Dick Eastman Review has probably reviewed any genealogy program that you are thinking of purchasing.
• Search his site at:-
• http://www.eogn.com/search

Which is the best program for YOU?

• Again, make a list of what is important to you!
• Then read software reviews
• Look at Mumford's Genealogical Software Report Card
• Look at Louis Kessler's Genealogy Software Links
• Evaluate, evaluate, evaluate.

Starting from Square One

• You might want to start with one of the free genealogy programs
• You can always upgrade to a more powerful program later
• You can transfer your data from the old program to the new one via a GEDCOM file
• Many people use two or more genealogy programs at more or less the same time: they may prefer the record keeping capabilities of one program and the printed reports of another
• With GEDCOM, you are not constrained to one program

• This magazine provides a cover CD with Genealogy related programs and much more.
• Often the programs are full versions and there are usually trial versions of popular programs.
• Cover price is £4.99 but a discount will be obtained with a subscription
TWR Computing
• Trevor is a member of the Essex Society for Family History.
• He is always willing to discuss your needs with you
• I have flyers available for you to see what he can offer but note that I am not on commission.
• He has a web page at www.twrcomputing.co.uk

Remember

• Almost all the programs have downloadable demo versions.
• Those that do not have demo versions normally have a money-back guarantee.
- Don't be afraid to use it!
• Either way, you can try several programs at no financial risk.
• Experiment to find the program that best fits your needs.
• The one you prefer might not be the most powerful or have the best graphics or be the "best" at anything. However, it might simply "feel good." If so, that is the best program for you.

Legacy

• Arguably the best free genealogy program available today.
• http://www.legacyfamilytree.com
• A commercial version adds even more functionality
cc Chris Searl 19/05/2005 e-mail: chris@searlfamily.name

Ancestral Quest:

http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0301.htm

Ancestry Family Tree

• A free genealogy program that also integrates nicely with Ancestry.com's online genealogy databases
•
http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0150.htm and
http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0331.htm

Cumberland Family Tree

• A full review is available at
http://www.eogn.com/archives/news9631.txt
• followed by a later update at:
http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0043.htm

The Master Genealogist

• This is believed to be the most powerful genealogy program available today and has a very loyal customer base.
• It does require a bit more effort to learn its use, but those who become expert at The Master Genealogist usually do not switch to anything else:
• http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0221.htm
• http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0350.htm
• http://www.whollygenes.com.

RootsMagic

• A new, easy-to-use genealogy program with excellent credentials
• http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0251.htm

Personal Ancestral File

• A free genealogy program that is very popular
• Produced by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (the Mormons)
• You can download it online at no charge or buy it on CD-ROM
• The CD-ROM version also includes PAF Companion, an add-on utility not available with the downloadable version.
• http://www.familysearch.org/

Family Historian

http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0403.htm

Family Tree Legends

• A new and very good genealogy program that features ease-of-use along with very powerful features
• It also integrates nicely with a huge online database:
http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0414.htm
Heredis for Windows
• The best-selling genealogy program inFrance
• It is also available elsewhere:
http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0151.htm

Family Tree Maker

• Probably the best-selling genealogy program in the world, although not the most powerful.
• Family Tree Maker has a very strong emphasis on ease of use and graphics. It features excellent reports.

GRAMPS for Macintosh

• Is a free genealogy program that can be used on Macintosh OS X
• However, installation is very complex
- best attempted by a UNIX expert who thoroughly understands OS X's UNIX underpinnings.
- I would discourage all other Mac users from attempting to install GRAMPS.

Heredis for Macintosh

• Is an OS X state-of-the-art product from France
• It does an excellent job of combining a great user interface, a powerful and reliable genealogy database, and the multimedia files for which the Macintosh is famous.
• More information can be found at:
http://www.eogn.com/archives/news0342.htm

Personal Ancestral File for Macintosh

• Is available from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
• However, be aware that it is an aging program; it has not been updated in a long time
• It also has fewer features than almost all of today's current genealogy programs.
• Personal Ancestral File 2.3.1 works with Macintosh OS 6.0.5 through 9.2 systems.
• However, this program will not operate on Macintosh OS X in native mode.
• You can find more information at:
http://www.familysearch.org

Reunion for Macintosh

• This is a very powerful genealogy program that includes all the features expected in modern genealogy software.
• When you order Reunion, you actually receive two versions in the same box:
- One for Macintosh system 8.5 to 9.2
- And another that is a native OS X program.
• The two are virtually identical in functionality, but each one is optimised and designed for its native operating system.
• The OS X version of Reunion runs in native mode and brings you the Aqua interface.
• More information can be found at:
http://www.leisterpro.com/

Ancestoral Author

• Ancestral Author is a Windows program that constructs hyperlinked Adobe Acrobat PDF files from GEDCOM files, text files, images, and other user inputs. It is very simple to use, and creates high quality documents that can be printed, emailed, published on the internet, or sent to a service bureau for conversion into a bound book.
• http://www.ancestralauthor.com/

Gedcom Census

• is a free application designed to be used with Calico Pie's Family Historian to allow faster and more convenient creation of census source records with occupation attributes, census events and birth events linked to the sources. Gedcom Census is in no way associated with or endorsed by Calico Pie.
• It can be used with any Gedcom File
• http://www.fhug.org.uk/cgi-bin/index.cgi?action=viewnews&id=111

GEDCOM Utilities

• A collection of various utilities including GedLiving which enables you to modify a Gedcom file to exclude data for living people before publishing your file.
• When I tried to register I found the author was no longer contactable so although shareware, the
programs will be free until the web site is updated or removed.
• http://www.rootsweb.com/~gumby/ged.html

Question

• Brian Wilcock asks:-
• How do the various programs handle census data? my current one ignores it in its documentation, so I have the choice of a) creating a custom event and attaching the data in the 'source' field, repeating this for every individual covered or b) typing it into the 'notes' field for every individual. Is there an easier way? Ideally I would like to enter the data just once and refer all individuals to this.

Answer

• There are almost as many ways of recording census data in family history programs as there are users! It is quite a complex subject.
• One answer is to consider using Gedcom Census which is a free download from
http://www.fhug.org.uk/cgibin/index.cgi?action=viewnews&id=111
• Local
• It was developed specifically for Family Historian users which is a program that saves its data in the Gedcom format.

Question

• Brian Wilcock asks again:-
• Documents: I am currently limited to a text-only notes field for each individual, but would like to embed, or point to, fully-formatted multi-page 'Word' documents with many embedded photographs; possibly even with hot-linked data such as BMD or the census info covered above.
• "Dream on"? or does any program approach this?

Answer

• There are two possibilities that I am aware of, there may well be others.
• The Master Genealogist can achieve this but is only for people prepared to climb a steep learning curve.
• Family Historian has good multimedia facilities including linking in Word documents or any type of file such as a pdf, and the ability to select precise areas of a scanned photograph or document and link those areas to the person or people concerned. For instance you could have
one scanned image of a census page linked to Family Historian, and link the individual lines in
that image to the individual people concerned.


Please contactwith any queries
© Berkshire Family History Society 2007

updated 1 Sep 2007